All of these codes have been shared on CodePen and should be reusable on any project. When the icon was to the left of the label, user task time decreased. The research study points that the perceived icon function differs based on the OS the user is used to use. Chevron pointing to the right and chevron pointing down still makes the most sense to me. Next time, we’ll be diving into visual design, conversion rate optimization (CRO), how to design inclusive forms, and more! Clicking the icon takes more time because it’s a smaller target than the label. This is the UX Design Process Best Practices ebook, written by Jerry Cao, Ben Gremillion, Kamil Zięba, and Matt Ellis, and originally published on The effect is really cool and surprisingly supports click events. I don’t think I have EVER seen an expanding stack with a chevron on the right. Advertise here with BSA. Both work great and will vary based on the needs of each project. But each interface works differently based on the circumstances of the layout & the type of website. Thanks for the insight. But think of the control you can offer visitors by organizing projects into larger categories and even sub-categories. Best Practices for Accordion Menu in Web Design. Same here, I disagree with the use of the ‘+’ icon to expand. 2. The code is free and downloadable if you want to try it out yourself. The word “accordion” typically conjures a mental image of your favorite polka band. What do you think about arrow icons to the left of a side menu item that doesn’t expand as an accordion? The author of the second study you cite even mentions that sample size was small.. You sold me on the concept of putting the icon to the left of the title but you haven’t sold me on what that icon should actually be. Working with JavaScript is still the safest choice, but as more people upgrade their web browsers we can hope to see a future with primary support for CSS3. UX stands for User Experience while UI refers to the term User Interface. Based on the research and analysis, designers should make the plus icon to the left the new standard. Sorry about that. A More Efficient Way to Display Data Tables, 3 Small Ways to Make Large Sidebar Menus Scannable, 6 Ways to Reduce Content Overload on List and Grid Layouts, Color Contrast Mistakes to Avoid on Buttons, BugHerd: Gather Website Feedback Without the Long Email Chain, A Faster Way to View Search Results with Fewer Clicks, Making the experience of the website memorable is more important than what the website says. Despite widespread 4G data availability, mobile networks are still generally slower than wifi or broadband services. This is likely to happen when two or more panels can be opened at a time. Focus on Speed. Granted these content displays also require dynamic effects for switching between page elements – so there are pros and cons to accordions. Why? Read the study again. Use Best Practices to Engage Blog Visitors. In short, when all the page content is relevant to users, it is more advantageous to show all the content at once, even if doing so results in longer pages. Although polka music can offer a rip-snorting good time, the term is associated with something different in the realm of web design. For retina devices, use images which are 2x the width while keeping … Jist, a clever concept to reduce overspending—a UX case study. All of the above are important considerations when designing mobile apps and websites. Take a look at this Designmodo tutorial which explains the process of accordion development in a nice tutorial. Plus, your buyers have a path laid out that tells them how they got there. He notes that in order for there to be a meaningful and valuable user experience, information must be: 1. Why do we need an icon at all? Given its benefits, it can be tempting to use accordions whenever possible, but this can often do more harm than good. With that in mind, we’ll take a look at a couple of essential tips for crafting the right user experience. If you prefer modern CSS3 animation check out the following tutorial: Codrops publishes very high-quality content and their accordion CSS3 tutorial is no exception. They’re more inclined to click the label and don’t think they have to click the icon to expand the menu. I’ve added another research study that supports the plus icon over the arrow. Mobile UX Best Practices. It’s the default style of hyperlinks and they work well. This is typical behavior when constructing an accordion menu because only one primary menu is open at any given time. Idea Theorem is Toronto based UI UX Agency. For me it always feels like I am adding something. So instead of having links listed vertically, tabs are used to manage shifting content. 5 UI and UX Tips For Mobile Form Design Best Practices . Translation for B2B websites: Always tell your buyers where they are when navigating your site. Not sure about you but I always approach with a best practice principle to begin with but with the discovery phase of any project this should be tested with their users or prospective users to get more accurate results. An alternative to JavaScript is the expandable accordion UI with CSS3. usability gui-design best-practice accordion collapsible-panels. What designers need is a consistent standard on how an accordion menu should look. The reason for this is the way designers…, Searching for information on websites isn’t as easy as you’d think. There is a point of view that UI design is something that is more artistically grounded (for those who have graphic, visual skills), and Usability Testing Accordion-Style Checkouts: 2 UX Pitfalls that 75% of Sites Neglect. 153 11 11 bronze badges. So the effect is somewhat different and offers a different user experience by comparison. Checkboxes allow users to select multiple items at once. Having a beautiful UX design with amazing conversion rates demands best practices for the eCommerce UX design. I also strongly disagree with the advice to use a plus icon. Not every website needs an accordion menu and you certainly won’t find them all the time. Notice how the menu will automatically close when opening a new section. There are major downsides to accordions. © Copyright UX Movement. At the core of UX is ensuring that users find value in what you are providing to them. Here’s an accordion dropdown I built a few years back that follows the recommended design pattern: Scenarios where there are more than 1 level of dropdown would also add volumes of pluses putting weight in the layout, while chevron and arrows are more compact to fit in such situation. Interaction design patterns can be thought of as the summative learnings of what has worked well in the past. 9 UX Design Best Practices and Ideas for Banking Websites. So why not apply this mentality to your blog – where your site visitors spend their time. When benchmarking checkout flows for the first time back in 2012, we found that 14% of the top 100 US e-commerce sites used an accordion-style checkout. These interfaces have grown a lot more popular in recent years with the expansion of JavaScript and more prominently jQuery. Keeping Link Styles Simple Isn’t a Bad Thing. The “+” icon comes with too many assumptions and baggage. Arrows & chevrons are clearer to me. Using an image alongside each title really helps to showcase the quality of the products, plus the active accordion has a horizontal line under it to separate it from other content. I should have there visually unappealing empty space instead icon? Below is an example of UX best practices in an email design: Images. New UX Design for Apple’s iPad Keyboard [Adobe Lightroom] February 2020 Usability Updates . There are times where I’ve found accordion FAQ pages that could have just listed content down the page without forcing me to click on each heading. UX is the Top Brand Differentiator in 2020 . Image sizes should be less than 1MB. The accordion also needs an affordance icon to represent menu collapsing. These two elements are usually misconstrued by assuming they have the same role. Unfortunately older browsers will never be backwards-compatible to support new CSS3 animation. Reviewing & understanding the user experience (UX) of Samsung Galaxy Z Flip . This finding makes sense because the plus sign is the mathematical symbol for addition. Findable: Content needs to be navigab… One example of a popular design pattern is the hamburger icon. But since most developers are already familiar with JavaScript, I’d like to cover the more advanced techniques. Email file sizes should be below 100KB. User experiences are important aspects of eCommerce websites. Use breadcrumb navigationon your site, whether that’s location-, attribution-, or path-based. Another research study on accordions found that users click the plus icon more than the arrow one. An accordion menu is one of the niftiest user interface controls. This example behaves similarly to the Codrops tutorial except all the animations are handled through jQuery. Touch-based interfaces have also allowed for swipeable image galleries that work nicely with computer mice too. People instantly think “add”….And am I adding another row? Nice article. Th… ... How I failed Microsoft’s interview as a UX Designer, and what you can learn from it. In accordion-style this can take many forms as vertical, horizontal, slidable, tabbed, you name it! But where you place your icon and what icon you use can affect user task time and expectations. Things like (demographic, ethnography etc). It was created by Norm Coxfor the Xerox Star, which was one of the first graphical user interfaces. I like to think of accordions as content management tools. You can’t not gauge what “most users” use and what about keyboard only users, mobile users can completely switch from their dominant mouse hand. Nowadays the biggest concerning factor would be the total number of visitors who don’t have JS-supported browsers. Windows users take the plus icon as an expander and mac users take de triangle for this function. Visitors would rather browse through different pages rather than sift through a long single-page design. When in the body of the page “X” tends to be used for “delete”. Granted you can always pick up a free plugin to rebuild something from scratch instead. However working with collapsible accordion content makes the latter a lot more reasonable. Your email address will not be published. They allow you to display a large number of menu options while conserving space. July 07, 2020. The study further found that the choice of icon affected user expectations. These patterns illustrate the best practices of the interactive experience. And when you use an “X”….Am I deleting a row? I’m going to change it on my site now. The nature of an accordion would call for automatic collapsing, but it might not be the best option in terms of usability. This choice depends largely on the website itself and how content is expected to behave. When it’s easy to use, it works the way users expect. Arrows or chevrons can be used to denote navigation between views, but also run into fewer interactions than + and -. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. When in the frame of the page or in a window title bar, “X” is interpreted as “close” instead of “delete”. 1. Accordions are popular because they allow developers to force large amounts of content into tiny spaces on the page. In those spaces, a user is liable to see the + icon used in multiple ways to add users, add items to a cart, add coupon codes, etc. View in action where would you place the plus? Each image is given some caption text which animates into view. Thanks for the advice on the icon! The source code is free to download but it should really serve as an example describing how this interface might work. May be the accordion icon could be choosen by some sort of platform sniffing. I think it is dangerous to think in terms of “most users”. All rights reserved. For one of the world’s most stylish audio equipment manufacturers, we aren’t surprised about the quality of the accordion design. Moreover, in the context of the products I work with, the + is used to indicate teh ability to add a new item. When the accordion displayed arrow icons, users expected that it would take them to a new page. A menu that expands must also collapse. If the content is viewable and the accordion is usable then where’s the harm? Just be sure that each accordion component has a real purpose. What if some item in the middle will not expand? Either way portfolio sites can be an excellent choice for accordion widgets. These could be sub-headings or even multiple levels – the point is to organize content in a way that makes navigation simpler than endless scrolling. This is usually vertical with a series of links hidden within sub-links. Mostly with larger menus or content which might behave cleaner using expandable sections. The user’s eyes have to travel a greater distance to the target. As you click on each item the list will collapse smaller for an easier view of the project. Radio buttons only allow one radio item to be selected. That’s why employing UX best practices for user retention is essential. See more ideas about Accordion, Web design, App design. It’s just as confusing as removing / closing with a -. what should I do when my sub menus has add option ? I am not a big fan of accordion in mobile development, because I believe that this behaviour is a web style user experience. More users interpreted the plus icon correctly than the arrow icon. See more ideas about App design, Accordion, Ui design. Research study link has been added. This confusion leads to accordion menus that are hard to use. Also the caption text is a bit larger and seems more smooth. But my point is to demonstrate that both CSS3 and JavaScript can be used to create most of these effects. What I like about this design is that it doesn’t rely on tabs or links or anything outside of the images themselves – so the content becomes the tabs. Can we get more details about it? It doesn't work because it's confusing. 1. vote. For accordions with many items, we tend to leave sections expanded, because the jumping around that occurs as a result of panels closing and opening at … Businesses that invest in UX see an increase in revenue and customer loyalty. Creating a more humane world for users by teaching others how to practice UX the right way through principled design techniques. Your email address will not be published. The only benefit is that CSS3 doesn’t require as much code and offers a simpler method of animation. I certainly do not want my accordion menus to signal the ability to add new objects (When it’s not possible, and does not make sense even if we implemented it that way). Apr 19, 2016 Blog 651 0. User experience (UX) plays a vital role in a company’s success. But that’s no reason to ignore the concept entirely. I’d like to wrap up this post by offering a collection of free open source code snippets. This means when opening a new section the previously-open section will close. Usable: Site must be easy to use 3. And you can build quick accordions if you use website builders or CMS engines like WordPress. But there are additional mobile UX best practices to follow to ensure the best possible user experience. Which icon you choose and where you place them affects how users use accordion menus. If you do, your product is sure to succeed. When I see “+ Section”, that strongly suggests ‘Add a section’, not open the accordion. Accordion v/s Tabs — When to use what while designing kick-ass UX! — What Next . A Standard for Accordion Menus. The icon is also closer to the label, which shortens the distance users have to scan. If the accordion is higher than the page, users can't see some of its options. It took them longer because they thought they had to click the icon to expand the menu. There are too many ways to design an accordion menu. You'll find tips and free source code for building your own accordion menu. Jake Rocheleau April 19, 2016 1 Comment 0 1.5k. What the Web UI Design Best Practices Guide Will Teach You. I failed as a designer at a startup – UX Collective. The word “accordion” typically conjures a mental image of your favorite polka band. You can achieve this through the use of: 1. Best Practices for Accordion Menu in Web Design . But before you use them, you should know the optimal way to design them for your users. Users shouldn’t feel like they are losing menu options when they collapse the menu. But this is not a mandatory feature and, in fact, most accordion menus allow every section to be open. Here are a handful of suggestions and commonly held best practices when dealing with the style and design of hyperlinks. Rest depends on the type of eCommerce websites. 10 Best Practices for User Experience (UX) Design in 2020. As always – test for your target users, apply best practices as you can and be prepared to be surprised when the user totally changes what you expect from them! However that’s not what we are talking about when referring to accordion menu. It doesn’t matter whether you agree in your head or not, it matters how users behave. 113 0. 1. Placing a chevron on the right side is more of an indicator of “next” than expand. The best web.ui design strikes that impeccable balance between captivating looks and effortless interaction. Using colors and shapes, can’t you simply make the accordion look tappable/clickable and completely eliminate the issue of icon recognition across varying people and cultures? Jun 23, 2017 - Explore Marc Levinson's board "Accordion UX" on Pinterest. Designmodo has a live sample preview which demonstrates how the menu behaves in action. Desirable: Image, identity, brand, and other design elements are used to evoke emotion and appreciation 4. There are too many ways to design an accordion menu. When the accordion displayed plus icons, users expected the menu to change. I just saw this right after reading this article. The seven best practices in this article are based on my work as a senior UX designer at SolutionSet, a marketing agency with a large social business practice. This action is more aligned with what users are doing and what they expect. What may seem right to you may not be right to them. Take for example the homepage of Toko which uses a dynamic portfolio listing. Perhaps because of the minimalist design, perhaps because of the grid-like structure. Hi Anthony, good stuff there. If your goal is to give users the most clarity and speed, there’s only one way to design it. So make sure you understand what onboarding UX is, why it’s so important, and the best practices that can help you improve your onboarding user experience. Written by Liam Burns . The hamburger icon went into hibernation for several years, but gained popu… Over the past decade this number has dwindled considerably low as more people are upgrading their computers. The UX writer is an increasingly recognizable job title, and many large corporations hunt for good UX writers. This means you should have almost no concern because even mobile smartphone browsers support JavaScript. Oct 8, 2018 - This post delves into the concept of accordion design for website interfaces. Thanks! This difference is because they’re more familiar with arrow icons on buttons and links that take users to a new page. The X icon represents collapsing better because it’s often used to close modal windows. Peter Morville represents this through his User Experience Honeycomb . This [new] site has the plus sign on the right hand side, then to show the open state they convert the plus to a minus sign. There are a ton of blog UX best practices for both content writers and designers to use. This confusion leads to accordion menus that are hard to use. Alas, I agree with placement on the left hand side of the item. Sometimes a website’s entire navigation menu is built on this accordion effect. ... Alternate UX / UI for accordion in Mobile Development. Another example of accordion content is based on tabbed widgets. I hope the day comes when ‘UX’ specialist stop going on their gut feeling and actually go on user needs and requirements. But even working closely together their roles refer to different design processes. Every accordion menu needs an affordance icon to tell users what happens when they click it. While accordions sound ideal for presenting complex content, like with many other widgets and implementations, they are not a one-size-fits-all solution. I’m not sure I agree that + and x are the best options for accordions for the same reason you exclude -. It’s used as more of a decorative bullet- do you think that would be confusing for the end user- assuming they expect that when they see an arrow it will expand? Many interfaces make use of add and remove features- particularly when dealing with shopping interactions or user management. One thing that sticks out here is the recommendation to use a +/x for accordion menus. But I’m missing a link to the actual study you are referring to. If your goal is to give users the most clarity and speed, there’s only one way to design it. asked yesterday. A research study found that user task time increased when the icon was to the right of the label. 😎 I am thinking to start a series of stories about very small, insignificant looking (but important, huge and relevant) features in design, that can make or break a kick-ass experience for the user! I don’t believe there is a catch-all best way to this type of thing. I’d like to state that either one of these effects could be duplicated and pushed onto the other – it’s simply a matter of recoding the design to fit the interface. In my opinion, an accordion might present problems in some situations: When it's too high. Using animation, colors, and hierarchal relationships, you shouldn’t need to use an icon at all to express to the user how this interaction functions. Using the checkbox method you can have many different content areas open at the same time. We … Hyperlink Design Best Practices. Clicking on a primary link will then expand the list of sub-links in a sliding animation. This eBook deep dives into web UI design best practices. 140 0. The plus icon is the clearer affordance for menu expansion. Breadcrumb navigation works like a GPS, telling your buyers where they are on your website at all times. Informing Initial UX Requirements If we were all mind readers, UX documentation wouldn’t be necessary. Getting back to Codrops I found another great tutorial covering an image accordion with CSS3. This is another really popular method of content management because JavaScript has made the process super easy. Other common choices are dropdown menus which appear on hover – but accordion menus don’t slide over the page since they’re built into the page. And of course there will always be those who prefer to build everything from scratch. Granted I understand the premise but if each answer can be surmised in a few sentences, hiding that content isn’t going to improve the user experience. Here are some best practices for UX for web projects. Page headers.The page header should resemble the copy of the navigation items or links. When you add, you increase in amount, number, or degree. It’s like an invisible hand guiding your users through the experience at the speed of thought. When you have a page that’s broken into dozens of paragraphs, links, images, or just too many blocks of content… accordion menus to the rescue. I have been trying to educate designers for years, that just because something looks good doesn’t make it more functional. When I read the article, I couldn’t quite agree with the plus/x icon in the shoes of a user, but thanks to your link (nice transition from plus to x by the way) I think I’m one step closer to understanding and agreeing it. Commentdocument.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "ad5ccc9f9b2bc4cca3c8514dbced504f" );document.getElementById("i995e0e57d").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); Large sidebar menus can frustrate even the most advanced user. Granted they both seem like a risk but CSS3 has much less browser support. Placing the icon to the left of the label speeds up user task time. It shows that no icon was one of the options tested. When it's nested inside another accordion. the idea of research takes out the guess work and you gain insight into what the user is doing or trying to do .. Jul 1, 2015 - This post delves into the concept of accordion design for website interfaces. what ties UI elements together with distinguishable and predictable actions Pretty cool right? 15 Stunning Examples of What You Need to See in a One-Page Website Design, The knowns and unknowns framework for design thinking, How I failed Microsoft’s interview as a UX Designer, and what you can learn from it, I failed as a designer at a startup – UX Collective, Jist, a clever concept to reduce overspending—a UX case study. I agree with your comment entirely. I wonder, has anyone thought about which hand most people use for the mouse? Make use of this sparingly but keep it in mind. Users increase the number of menu options when they click the accordion menu. I’d like to cover a series of examples and techniques for building accordion interfaces into any website layout. It should display in place of the plus icon after the user expands the menu. Great article – I think that some of this however does depend on a lot of outside factors that influence the research study. Do you have a link to the source research study? Design Should Concentrate on User Experience. A concur that there is a much greater confusion in using the plus, which is that of adding to the current collection. You are not the user. You can just as easily denote navigation through colored button elements, or a specific use of those buttons for navigation only. Each sample demonstrates the power of accordion content whether in a navigation, FAQ listing, or tabbed widget. When you think of UX, you think of providing visitors with an amazing experience. Following up on our recent tips on designing for inclusion and accessibility, in this 2-part series we’re taking a detailed look at best practices for form design.Today we’re starting with process, layout, engineering, text, and validation. Required fields are marked *. If people need to open the majority of subtopics to have their qu… hb20007. Author and founder of UX Movement. These UX design best practices will help you provide shoppers with a mobile experience that parallels what the tech giants are offering – app-like interactions on the web with Google’s Progressive Web Apps, speedy browsing (perceived and actual) on Facebook, and an efficient checkout process on Amazon. User interface accordions might refer to menus, widgets, or content areas which expand like the musical instrument. Smaller targets need higher accuracy to click. When users collapse the menu, they are closing it, not losing it. So when exactly should you use accordions? Very interesting, but I was wondering from which “study” did you get those insights ? I would be curious to see how this study would fare without the use of an icon…. In a similar vein as the portfolio listing is a collapsable image gallery.

ux accordion best practices

Asiatic Rhinoceros Beetle, Keeper Of The Lost Cities Read Online, Cartoon Drawing Girl, Tea Olive Problems, How Long Do Crabs Live, Female Athlete Nutrition Requirements, Who Owns Best Western Hotels Uk, Mold Bomb Fogger Home Depot, Nikon Z6 Vs Sony A7iii Video, Luxury Condos Ottawa, Personalized Map Art, Designer Men's Shirts, Can You Learn Piano On A 76 Key Keyboard,